The Conversation
11 Jul 2019, 11:51 GMT+10
As the debate over the Morrison government's plan to legislate against religious discrimination gathers heat, an Essential poll has found only 38% of Australians agree that stronger laws are needed to protect those who express their faith in public.
On the other hand, the poll found that 58% believed employers should not have the right to dictate what their employees say outside work.
When people were asked their opinion on various statements, 69% agreed with the statement, "it is only right that people consider how what they say can affect others." A high proportion - 64% - agreed that "people should not be allowed to argue religious freedoms to abuse others."
But 64% agreed that nowadays people were unlikely to say what they really think because they were afraid of how others would react.
Read more: Politics with Michelle Grattan: Father Frank Brennan on Israel Folau and religious freedom
Most respondents knew about the dispute between Rugby Australia and Israel Folau - who was sacked after a homophobic post based on the Bible - although people were divided over whether it was mainly about Folau's right to express his religious views (43%) or about whether Rugby Australia should be able to dismiss an employee who was in breach of his contract (49%).
Two-thirds (68%) agreed that Folau chose to share his religious views on social media and should take responsibility for them. About half (51%) agreed he had used his public profile to attack a minority group in the community.
Nearly half (46%) thought Folau's actions had damaged the Wallabies team and rugby in Australia, while just 34% believed he had the right to voice his religious views, regardless of the hurt it could cause others.
What various interest groups are saying
In an interview published by Guardian Australia this week, Attorney-General Christian Porter flagged that his proposed religious discrimination legislation would cover a situation like the Folau case.
Porter said the legislation would include a clause relating to indirect discrimination.
Porter is currently holding briefing sessions for Coalition backbenchers.
Prime Minister Scott Morrison has said he does not want the legislation to be divisive. But he is faced with a widening debate that will be difficult to manage.
Read more: Why Christians disagree over the Israel Folau saga
Hard-line conservatives in the Liberal party want the government to go further than it is inclined. But the free-market Institute of Public Affairs is warning about unintended consequences of legislation. And advocacy groups for women and gays are agitated that the legislation - the origins of which was as a sop to the losing side in the same-sex marriage debate - could lead to new discrimination.
The women's group Fair Agenda has joined with LGBTIQ advocacy organisation Equality Australia to ask the government to ensure people of faith, women and LGBTIQ people "are protected equally."
The groups, who want a meeting with the government, warned on Tuesday that inappropriately drafted provisions could override existing legal protections for LGBTIQ people and women, and undermine employers' ability to maintain safe and inclusive workplaces.
They are also concerned about
John Roskam, executive director of the IPA, told Sky that while there were concerns over people of faith being driven from the public square, the government's proposals, from the little known thus far, were counterproductive.
Read more: Why the Israel Folau case could set an important precedent for employment law and religious freedom
He said the IPA's broader argument was that the difficult challenges
Roskam said there was also a risk of
Author: Michelle Grattan - Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra
Get a daily dose of Israel Herald news through our daily email, its complimentary and keeps you fully up to date with world and business news as well.
Publish news of your business, community or sports group, personnel appointments, major event and more by submitting a news release to Israel Herald.
More InformationLONDON, U.K.: At least 13 people are believed to have taken their own lives as a result of the U.K.'s Post Office scandal, in which...
WASHINGTON, D.C.: Travelers at U.S. airports will no longer need to remove their shoes during security screenings, Department of Homeland...
WASHINGTON, D.C.: An elaborate impersonation scheme involving artificial intelligence targeted senior U.S. and foreign officials in...
SLUBICE, Poland: Poland reinstated border controls with Germany and Lithuania on July 7, following Germany's earlier reintroduction...
WASHINGTON, D.C.: After months of warnings from former federal officials and weather experts, the deadly flash floods that struck the...
MOSCOW, Russia: Just hours after his sudden dismissal by President Vladimir Putin, Russia's former transport minister, Roman Starovoit,...
NEW YORK CITY, New York: Former British prime minister Rishi Sunak will return to Goldman Sachs in an advisory role, the Wall Street...
LONDON, U.K.: Physically backed gold exchange-traded funds recorded their most significant semi-annual inflow since the first half...
AMSTERDAM, Netherlands: Some 32 percent of global semiconductor production could face climate change-related copper supply disruptions...
NEW YORK, New York - U.S. stocks rebounded Tuesday with all the major indices gaining ground. Markets in the UK, Europe and Canada...
NEW YORK CITY, New York: Financial markets kicked off the week on a cautious note as President Donald Trump rolled out a fresh round...
RIO DE JANEIRO, Brazil: At a two-day summit over the weekend, the BRICS bloc of emerging economies issued a joint declaration condemning...